Handcrafted Cheesecake Flavours & Sizes

Sharps Cheesecakes offers a rotating selection of small-batch, made-to-order cheesecake flavours baked fresh in Coldwater, Ontario. Each cheesecake begins with a buttery graham cracker or cookie crust, is filled with a rich and creamy cheesecake batter, and is finished by hand with toppings that complement the flavour — from smooth salted caramel and bright lemon curd to fresh strawberries, spiced pumpkin, and crushed chocolate cookies. Whether you are celebrating a birthday, hosting a holiday dinner, or simply treating yourself, there is a flavour here for every taste and occasion.

Classic favourites include chocolate fudge, salted caramel, peanut butter chocolate, and cookies & cream for the chocolate lovers, alongside fruit-forward options like blueberry, strawberry, and lemon cheesecake. Seasonal specials such as pumpkin and apple crumble make an appearance through the year, and custom flavour requests are always welcome — just note your request in the order form and we will do our best to bring it to life. Every cheesecake is homemade, made with quality ingredients, and baked with care, so no two orders are ever quite the same.

Cheesecakes are available in several sizes to suit your gathering. A 4-inch mini is perfect for an individual treat, a 7-inch suits smaller gatherings, an 8-inch is ideal for family celebrations, a 9-inch is a popular choice for birthdays, a 10-inch serves larger parties, and an 11-inch is made for bigger special occasions. Prices start at $10 for a mini and scale up to $90 for an 11-inch, with specialty flavours potentially carrying an additional charge. Orders are placed through the website and picked up locally in Coldwater, Ontario.